This story is the most common encounter that happened at the Warren's store. One day, a man and his girlfriend rode into town on a motorcycle. They stopped at the Warren's museum, they walked in and headed straight for Annabelle. "Hey, do something to me, you won't. C'mon do something," the man said as he knocked on the glass case. The girlfriend laughed, but the worker didn't. "Please, you must leave," he said. On their way home, they got into a car crash. The man died, but the girfriend survived. To this day, everyone knows it was Annabelle.